Silk vs Down Duvet: Differences + Pros and Cons

So my girlfriend and I have finally made the decision to move in together. After months of going back and forth with the idea, she has finally given the green light. However, after living in a studio apartment for so long all by myself, you could understand my dread of having to spruce up every single corner of my living space, including my bed.

Silk vs Down Duvet

Bed [/bɛd/] noun
A place you wait all day to go and don’t want to leave.

There are a lot of options to pick from but I’m currently deciding between silk vs. down duvet. These snug beddings are made to give you the definitive sleeping experience with its terrific comfort and breathability.

However, the two have identical characteristics so it was quite difficult for me to decide which one to get, without doing some fair amount of research. My girlfriend is taking her moving in with me seriously so it’s only right that I take this task seriously as well.

In doing my due diligence to find out what are the differences between silk and down duvets, I uncovered that they are both extremely comfortable, soft, and give you a luxurious feeling that makes every bed a warm and comfy sleep sanctuary. These duvets are also designed to guarantee an exact fit and long-lasting quality.

Silk duvets feature high-quality silk filling that just embraces the entire body with sufficient warmth and comfort all night long without leaving behind that clammy feeling. And because these are lightweight and highly breathable, silk comforters give your skin a mild touch.

On the other hand, down duvets are filled with down feathers that are often taken from the girth of geese and ducks. Which means, if you like your comforter to be heavy, go for down.

If you want to learn more about the pros and cons of silk and down duvets, some helpful shopping tips as well as our recommendations for the best silk and down comforters in the market today, continue reading useful guide!

Interested in seeing the best silk and down duvets without the detailed explanation? CLICK HERE

Table of Contents

Not up to read through our whole guide? Just use our table of contents to see the sections most relevant to you!

  1. Tips for Buying Silk Comforters
  2. Guide to Buying Down Comforters
  3. Silk vs. Down Comforter Comparison
  4. Pros and Cons of Silk and Down
  5. Top Rated and Recommended Silk Comforters
  6. Top Rated and Recommended Down Comforters

Tips for Buying Silk Comforters

The rising demand for a better quality of sleep has given rise to a demand for high-quality beddings, such as great comforters or sheets. In this section, I am going to introduce to you several tips for choosing high-quality and suitable silk comforters.

Silk vs Down Comforter Comparison

What Are Silk Comforters

Silk comforter is those comforters that are made of 100% silk floss. It usually comes in two kinds: one is with silk case/cove, while the other is with a cotton case.

Silk Shell or Cotton Shell?

When shopping for silk comforters, you may come across those terms: silk comforter with silk shell or silk comforter with a cotton shell. So, what are those and which is better?

To be clear, both of them are filled with 100% silk. The biggest distinction lies in their case or cover. The silk comforter with a silk shell, or called silk-covered comforter is the one with silk case covered on the silk floss. In comparison, the outer shell of a silk comforter with cotton shell, also called cotton-covered comforter, is composed of cotton.

You can enjoy silk benefits from either one of these. You can pick a cotton-covered silk comforter if budget is a huge factor or you do not want the comforter to move around a lot on your bed. Silk-covered silk comforter, meanwhile, would be an ideal choice if you would like to experience a completely silky dream and the price is not an issue.

Should You for Handmade or Machine?

I would definitely suggest handmade silk comforter for the following reasons:

Handmade silk comforters are filled using long fiber Silk. The silk floss is:

  • Layered in a grid pattern.
  • Tacked, not boxed stitched.
  • No lumps caused by silk filling clumping up.

Machine silk comforters are filled with short fibers that are:

  • Stuffed, not layered into a casing.
  • Box stitched, which damages the silk fiber and creates cold spots throughout the comforter, undermining a silk comforter’s heat-regulating ability.

Do You Need a Cover For Your Silk Comforter?

Yes, most definitely. You should always safeguard your comforter with a cover to keep dust or damage that is caused by unexpected factors.

What is the Best Type of Silk Comforters?

It goes without saying that 100% silk should always your first choice especially when it comes to the silk floss. Only the cocoons of silkworm can be unraveled to make spindles of single-strand silk threads, resulting in long-stranded silk fiber.

Is OEKO-Certification Important?

Yes! The OEKO certification is the most trusted authority for quality inspection in the home and textile field. The test label, therefore, is a significant decision-making tool when you are out shopping for bed linen.

Heard enough about duvets? Get my silk comforter recommendations now!

Guide to Buying Down Comforters

While down offers you warmth during the more frigid seasons of the year, it is also popular for the breathable, lightweight and natural elements that make it a fine choice for the use all year round. And rest assured, these would also be suitable with your best down pillows. So, if you are considering buying a down comforter, there are some crucial matters that you need to be made aware of before making your purchase.

What Are the Differences Between Silk and Down Duvets

Down comforters may differ from one another depending on their price points and styles. You can go for a top-of-the-line goose down comforter or a polyester-filled one. Whatever kind of down comforter you end up with, it is very important that you take note of the most fundamental things that you need to consider before making a purchase. Here are some guidelines that you need to bear in mind when you are shopping for a down comforter:

Types of the Best Down Comforters

Down refers to a bird’s undercoat that is utilized for its lightweight and ultra-soft quality. Set side by side to an actual bird’s feather, down doesn’t have brittle and hard quills nor does it have stiff and flat shape either.

  • This is the most preferred kind of down comforter used by a lot of families these days and it often comes available in a mixture of gray and white goose down. Essentially, the color of the down has nothing to do with the quality. Many people like to buy white goose down because it does not show through the white shells of the comforter.
  • Many producers of down comforter all around the world favor using goose down but there are also those that make down comforters using duck down. However, comforters that are made from duck down are usually found in the low-end category.
  • Choices and preferences differ from one person to another and this proves to be true when picking a down comforter. There are those who do not like using down-filled comforters so they often go for the ones that have alternative materials. With such selections, you can still get the down properties to achieve comfort and hypoallergenic quality.

The Fill Power

Fill power signifies how an ounce of down is measured in relation to a particular amount of space it takes up. Ideally, fill power comforters can be found in the higher end category of down comforters. If a down comforter has a high level of fill power, then this often means it features better insulation, loft, and fluffiness. By way of fill power, you can easily say whether or not a down comforter is of high quality and warmth or not. The following are the different kinds of down comforters according to their fill power:

  • Up to 400 = lightweight, warm and soft
  • 400 to 599 = gives you warmth the whole year round
  • 600 – 799 = a warmer choice that exudes lightweight quality
  • 800 and above = delivers the highest insulation for the winter season

The Thread Count

Like any other bedding and comfort sheets, a higher thread count commonly means a much softer quality because of their tightly weaved characteristic. When it comes to down comforters, tighter weave due to higher thread count defines how it holds the down fill well in order to last you a longer period of time.

In order to attain high-quality thread count, it is crucial for you to make sure that there should be a proper balance between the thread count and the weave. You need to bear in mind that a high thread count can also be a great indicator of poor quality fabric and inferior weave construction.

The Different Types of Construction

When looking for a down comforter, just taking a close look at its style should not be the only thing that you need to train your attention on. You also need to contemplate the stitching styles and construction of the comforter. The following are the different types of down comforter construction:

  1. Baffle Box – This kind of comforter exudes fabric strips known as baffles. They are often sewn and attached between the bottom and top layers of a comforter, which results in compartments or rooms for the fill. The walls of the baffle allow for full expansion of the down to achieve the highest level of fluffiness and maximum cushion.
  2. Walls are made around the comforter’s outer edge, connecting the bottom and top layers. Maximum loft and fluffiness are achieved with the added height of the edges. Gusset comforters can either be constructed using sewn-through or baffle box method. However, a gusseted comforter usually comes in baffle box or box stitch.
  3. Diamond Quilted – The bottom and top layers of a comforter are sewn and attached together, with the use of a diamond pattern. With this, fill shifting is eliminated.
  4. Karo Step – To diminish the shifting of fill, a comforter should have open compartments. This is something that you can get from a Karo Step comforter. When open compartments are present in a comforter, free movement of the fill is allowed. This is often made in a baffled or sewn-through style.
  5. Sewn Through Box Stitch – The bottom and top layers of the comforter are sewn together with the use of a box pattern to get rid of fill shifting.
  6. Sewn Through Channel Stitch – The bottom and top layers of the comforter are sewn and attached together in vertical and horizontal rows. This allows free movement of the comforter’s fill.
  7. Ring Stitch – The comforter’s bottom and top layers are sewn together in small circles. This is similar to the Karo Step that allows the comforter’s fill to move around.

The Benefit of Using Down Comforters

Possessing a down comforter and the best memory foam mattresses would really make your sleep more comfortable. Here are some other benefits that you can enjoy with a down comforter:

  • The warmth that you get from the comforter is unparalleled. This is because a down comforter has the ability to keep body heat within its filling.
  • A down comforter also works just as great even during the summer season. A down comforter features breathability that lets moisture and sweat to pass through its filling. This makes for a fine choice for warm sleepers who are looking for comforters that won’t allow them to overheat.
  • A down comforter is often made from lightweight materials that let you make and set your bed fairly easily during the night and in the morning, providing you comfort even in the coldest months of the year.
  • A down comforter does not need high maintenance. As a matter of fact, it only needs to be washed two to three times every year.

Now you know the benefits of down – check out my duvet recommendations!

Silk vs. Down Comforter Comparison

Pros and Cons of Silk and Down

Let’s make a quick appraisal between silk and down comforters:

1. Price

Prices for down comforters roughly range between $250-$350 on Amazon and $250-$400 for silk comforters. On more dedicated online shops, the pricing of both down and silk comforters can greatly differ, going straight up to the 4-digit range. Overall, pricing for both types of comforters is identical in nature.

2. Warmth

Down comforters keep all heat emanated by your body inside because air pockets created by down feathers inside the comforter are stationary. This makes down comforters great especially if your bedroom is very cold during winter. However, if your room is not air-conditioned, sleeping in a down comforter will cause you to sweat profusely after a particular period of time passes due to the temperature inside the comforter keeps rising up.

Silk comforters are thinner and more breathable because of the mesh structure of the filling, so in general, they tend to be a bit “cooler.” Of course, for a judiciously air-conditioned space, silk comforters will fare better since it will regulate temperature around your body naturally by allowing excessive heat to escape. This is the reason why silk comforters can be utilized in a variety of temperatures all through the year while down comforters are generally used for winter.

3. Comfort and Sleep Quality

Down Comforters

  • Down comforters are fairly heavy compared to silk comforters, which means sleepers have a more difficult time moving around while in a down comforter and have more restricted blood flow around the body.
  • Down comforters are toasty, although, at times, too warm which results in excessive perspiration. If the shell of the comforter/duvet cover is not made of a material that features great moisture wicking capabilities, sweating too much creates a damp sleeping environment which, you should all know by now, is not very comfortable. Sweating too much also causes dehydration that may bother your sleep, and leave you feeling more tired in the morning.
  • Down comforters are fairly rigid and need to be tucked in around the shoulders to keep warm. This needs to be done on a consistent basis all through the night. Failure to do so makes the stomach area warm but shoulders cold, which causes your nervous system to be unable to rest.
  • Most down comforters keep their filling distributed evenly by sewing equal portions of down feathers in different pockets in the comforter. However, lower quality down comforters has the issue of cold spots because even within the smaller pockets the down feathers can still “bunch up” and make a denser cluster that occupies just a section of the pocket instead of spreading all throughout. This makes an area that is completely uncovered through which heat escapes freely. Obviously, this is not ideal for insulation.

Silk

  • Silk comforters are light and sleeping in a silk comforter can be very relaxing. However, for a restless sleeper, silk comforters tend to get pushed off the bed fairly often.
  • Silk comforters work great as temperature regulators as well as great moisture wickers, which means that you will rest at an ideal temperature all through the night. Even if you are the type that sweats a lot, the comforter will help eliminate excess moisture and keep the environment adequately dry.
  • Silk comforters are soft which means they drape naturally over the contours of your body no matter how you often you move around. Your body will be amply protected from the cold and no partially-cold-partially-hot feelings will happen.
  • Silk comforters’ fillings are sheet-like and evenly distributed when it comes to thickness. The sides of the filling are usually tacked on the edge of the comforter shell, which forces the filling to stay still, so there will be no cold spots.

4. Maintenance

Down comforters usually use a cotton shell that needs to be washed often, since cotton is not all too resistant to mold, bacteria and dust mites. However, down comforters are best washed with dry cleaning, which means that maintaining a down comforter well is not only expensive but also time-consuming. The overheating issue of down comforters further complicates this problem since more sweat tends to result in the easier formation of molding spots.

Silk comforters, on the other hand, are also not water-washable. However, compared to down comforters, silk is anti-bacterial, anti-mold and anti-acarid, which means that apart from airing your comforters once in a while to eliminate any residual moisture in the filling, a silk comforter doesn’t need to be dry cleaned as much. In addition, since silk comforters can be used throughout the year and are thinner than down comforters, you do not need to be worried about putting the comforter away or look for extra storage space.

So, to give you a recap of the pros and cons of a silk comforter and a down duvet here’s a useful list that you can refer to when you are out shopping for one:

Pros and Cons of Silk and Down

Silk Comforter

Pros

  • Comfortable, soft, smooth, and lightweight
  • Breathable
  • Adapts to various seasons of the year
  • Does not leave hot spots or cause under heating
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Provides insulation during winter and coolness when the temperatures get hot
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Silk fillings are versatile, durable, do not shrink easily
  • Drapes beautifully

Cons

  • Some people may find it too much for their budget

Down Duvet

Pros

  • Very comfortable, soft, smooth and has a little sheen
  • A bit on the heavy side
  • Usually filled with thick down filling
  • Delivers excellent insulation during cold temperatures
  • Has lightweight options depending on the amount of filling
  • Easy to clean
  • Also has affordable options

Cons

  • Can shelter bacteria and moisture because of its heavy weight; may sometimes leave a sticky feeling
  • Not as hypoallergenic as silk
  • Because of its thickness, it may not give you enough coolness during warmer months

Top Rated and Recommended Silk Comforters

Silk vs Down Duvet Silk Pick 1

1) Silk Camel Luxury Allergy-free Comforter

  • Provides warmth in winter and and comfort in summer
  • Moisture-free to keep allergens and debris from entering
  • Keeps allergies and rheumatism at bay

Price & Reviews

The Silk Camel Luxury’s comforter is an all-natural item that is worthy of having on your bedside. It is really silky and, at 8.8 pounds, it gives you excellent comfort and warmth from the cold winter months and hot summer months. It keeps moisture away from your body, which helps prevent allergens and other debris which might cause you problems such as allergies or rheumatism.

Furthermore, its silk exterior helps you elude pesky issues such as bed bugs, dust mites, mold, and mildew. Silk Camel Luxury’s comforter is also convenient as it is extremely easy to carry around with you should you decide to head out and travel while staying in hotels, hostels, Airbnbs, and other places.

Silk vs Down Duvet Silk Pick 2

2) LilySilk All-Season Silk Comforter with Silk Shell

  • 100% silk mulberry floss
  • 400 TCI to keep its shape
  • Smooth and breathable for comfort

Price & Reviews

Made of 100 percent silk mulberry floss, LilySilk’s All-Season silk comforter is a legitimate comforter that people definitely need in their lives to feel not only warm and cozy but also at peace with. In addition, it also has an outer silk shell, that consists of a 400 TCI and 100-percent 19 Momme Natural Luxurious long-strand silk that will keep its shape, all while preserving the integrity of the inner layer from long-term use. It is smooth and breathable, and it does a fine job of wicking away moisture to control your body’s temperature, whether hot or cold.

What makes LilySilk’s all-season silk comforter distinct from all others in the market is its side zipper, which makes it easy to access anytime to inspect for irregularities from time to time. It gives you the ultimate sleeping experience, whether it is for naps or for a good night’s sleep.

Silk vs Down Duvet Silk Pick 3

3) 100% Pure Long Grade Mulberry Silk Duvet

  • 100% cotton sateen casing for the ultimate luxury
  • Easily stored in vacuum storage bags
  • Lightweight for spring and autumn

Price & Reviews

Moon’s Sleepwares’ queen-sized comforter is made of 100-percent cotton sateen casing, which gives you that beautiful luxury that makes you feel all kingly or queenly. Despite its fairly large size – 220/230 cm – it can be wrapped up and neatly tied, and it is easy to assemble once rolled out; it even has its own vacuum bag and cotton storage bag, should you need to store it for later use.

Additionally, it is lightweight and clean, making it suitable for spring and autumn seasons or even all season. It is breathable, thereby able to remain clean and tidy in spite of the number of times you use it.

Silk vs Down Duvet Silk Pick 4

4) LilySilk All Season Luxury Silk Comforter with Cotton Covered 100% Silk Duvet

  • 100% silk mulberry floss
  • 300 TCI to keep a silk shell outside
  • Smooth and breathable

Price & Reviews

The LilySilk All Season Luxury Silk Comforter is made from 100-percent silk mulberry floss, which gives you the “real deal” when it comes to feeling comfortable and warm. Not only that, it has an outer silk shell, which is comprised of 300 TCI and 100-percent pure and natural long strand silk floss that will keep its shape, all while keeping the inside intact over an extended period of time. It is smooth and breathable, and it can wick away moisture to regulate body temperature.

This LilySilk All Season Luxury Silk Comforter is distinctive in that it features a side zipper, which makes it easily accessible to inspect at any time. In all, it is sure to give you a good night’s sleep every single time.

Silk vs Down Duvet Silk Pick 5

5) ZIMASILK Mulberry 100% Long Grade Mulberry Silk Comforter

  • Eco-friendly for guilt-free sleep
  • Naturally hypoallergenic and mildew resistant
  • Great for both summer and winter

Price & Reviews

Zimasilk’s silk comforter offers you 100-percent eco-friendly cotton and mulberry silk that is not only great for keeping you all warm and toasty and smooth while having a good night’s sleep but also works great for preserving the environment. It is naturally hypoallergenic, as well as mildew-resistant, which proves you with great protection from irritations in the air, leaving you allergy-free.

In addition, Zimasilk’s silk comforter is remarkable when it comes to its versatility; aside from shielding you from the cold winter months, it can also keep you cool and collected during the hot summer.

Top Rated and Recommended Down Comforters

Silk vs Down Duvet Down Pick 1

1) Luxurious Siberian Goose Down Comforter

  • 100% Egyptian Cotton Cover
  • Medium warmth for all-year comfort
  • Hypoallergenic and allergy-free

Price & Reviews

With a down comforter like this one, you can enjoy all the opportunities to wrap yourself with something that’s made of 100% Egyptian cotton. It is considered to be a superior type of down comforter as it is worthy of an elegant and classy suite. No wonder, this kind of down comforter is often found in luxury and world-class hotels.

Luxurious Full-Queen Size Siberian Goose Down Comforter comes with 1200 threads per square inch and is made from Long Staple Giza Cotton which is grown in the lush valley of Nile River since the period of the Pharaohs. Simply, this is considered as the ultimate choice when it comes to luxurious sleeping. It oozes opulence, superior quality, and comfort that set and put it in a class above the rest.

Silk vs Down Duvet Down Pick 2

2) SNOWMAN White Goose Down Comforter

  • 100% Cotton
  • Warm breathable white goose down
  • Year-round comfort

Price & Reviews

This down comforter is a product of Snowman, a reputable maker of high quality and affordable down comforters. Snowman White Goose Down Comforter Full/Queen Size is, in fact spectacularly affordable. It is a real goose down duvet that will prove irresistible to anyone in the family.

It comes with large down clusters that mean your comforter will remain puffy and light for an extended period of time. While this comforter is popular for its breathable element, it will keep you warm even during the summer nights.

Silk vs Down Duvet Down Pick 3

3) Egyptian Bedding 800 Thread Count Hungarian Goose Down Comforter

  • 100% Egyptian Cotton Cover
  • Year-round comfort
  • 100% Hungarian Goose Down

Price & Reviews

This down comforter comes from the Egyptian Bedding collection that oozes of luxury and only weighs 50 ounces. It comes with a fill power of 750 and is made with baffle box designs. With its excellent construction, you can rest, assured that the fill is distributed evenly. It is woven to 800 threads per square inch.

It is also made from luxury downs that are made from Long Staple Giza cotton which are grown in the valley of the Nile River. With this kind of down comforter, you simply get the feeling that you are embraced by the clouds each time you go to sleep.

Silk vs Down Duvet Down Pick 4

4) Luxurious 1200 Thread Count Goose Down Comforter Duvet Insert

  • 100% Egyptian Cotton Cover
  • Hypoallergenic
  • 100% Goose Down

Price & Reviews

Luxurious 1200 Thread Count Goose Down Comforter is another fine product made by Egyptian Bedding, a world-renowned producer of high-quality bedding made from natural and high quality down and feathers. This comforter has a channel construction so the filling of the comforter can move freely. The superior construction also makes for even distribution of the down.

It is woven to a luxurious 1200 threads per square inch, making it a member of the high-end class down comforters. Like any other down comforters of Egyptian Bedding, Luxurious 1200 Thread Count Goose Down Comforter delivers to you that plush feeling as you sleep the night away regardless of what season of the year it is.

Silk vs Down Duvet Down Pick 5

5) Topsleepy 50% Goose Down and 50% Feather Filling Twin Comforter

  • 100% Cotton
  • Gives skin a natural protective film
  • Provides warmth all year round

Price & Reviews

Luxurious All Size Bedding Goose Down Filling Comforter gives you maximum comfort and superior warmth all year round. When I say that, it just means that this down comforter can be used not only during the winter season but during the hot summer nights as well.

This down comforter comes with the lowest price tag, making it an excellent choice for people who are looking forward to buying a down comforter at a price below $100.

Leave a Comment